A reader writes in, asking:
“You have mentioned a few times that you were a financial advisor with Edward Jones early in your career. My oldest child will be graduating in May next year, and a local Jones advisor/manager is trying to recruit her to come on board as an advisor after graduation.
I am aware that they still use the old-school commission type of compensation for their advisors, which is often not the best from the client’s point of view. But what I am most interested in knowing is whether you were ever asked to do anything that felt like it was against the client’s interests, or were you generally free to operate as you saw fit, according to your own ethics and best practices.”
A relevant point here is that I worked at Edward Jones for just under a year, and I was 21-22 at the time. So while there is still quite a bit about financial planning that I don’t know, it’s safe to say that I knew much less back then. Point being, there were an assortment of things that they told us to do, which I now realize were less than ideal, but which I just accepted at the time because I didn’t yet know any better.
But, yes, there was one instance that really made me uncomfortable, even with my very limited knowledge.
Immediately after we got our licenses, we were brought back in for a week of sales training at the home office. During that week, two of the days were spent making phone calls to prospective clients whom we had met over the last few months, in order to pitch them an investment product.
We didn’t get to choose the product. On the first day we had to pitch an individual bond. We could choose between a corporate bond (one from General Electric) or an AAA-rated muni bond from the state in which the client lived. I went with the muni bond. I knew it wouldn’t be ideal for plenty of the people I was calling (after all, I had no idea about their tax situation or about the rest of their portfolio), but at least it wasn’t likely to blow up on them.
On the following day, we had to pitch an individual stock. Even back then, I wasn’t at all on board with the idea of selling somebody an individual stock, especially while knowing almost nothing about the person in question. If they put, say, $20,000 into this stock, is that a trivial amount for them? Or are they going to be in a serious predicament if the stock goes south?
In addition, we had a supervisor listening in on the phone call, without the prospect’s knowledge. And we were in a loud room, full of people making similar calls. It was about as far as away from financial planning as you can get.
I remember making a point of calling all my worst prospects (that is, people who I knew were very unlikely to become clients), calling the same numbers repeatedly over the course of the day (i.e., calling people who weren’t home 20 minutes ago, in the hope that that would still not be home now), and intentionally flubbing my sales pitch when I did actually get a hold of somebody.
My plan was to just make it through those two days, then go back to my office in Chicago and run things in a way with which I was more comfortable: constructing diversified mutual fund portfolios. (In fact, this course of action was explicitly recommended to me by the manager in the Chicago region where I was working. Even as a long-term Edward Jones broker — somebody very comfortable with a sales/commission type of advisory role — he thought that the home office’s boiler room-style sales training was terrible for both clients and advisors.)
This was ~13 years ago, so I don’t know in what ways their training process has or hasn’t changed since then. Nonetheless, Edward Jones’ business model is still based on fundamental conflicts of interest between the client and the advisor, and I would not recommend it as a place to work as an advisor (nor as a place to invest as a client).
If at all possible, for a recent graduate interested in working in financial planning, I would instead suggest
Michael Kitces’ approach of trying to get a position not as a financial advisor but rather in an operations/support role at a financial advisory firm with a good reputation and client-centric business model. Any place that will hire people as full-fledged advisors right out of undergrad (and with no certifications) is almost certainly going to be employing those people in a product-focused sales role rather than actual financial planning.
Brief tangent: as it happens, the two stocks were Coca Cola and Bank of America. This was in April of 2006. Coca Cola has done great over the period — considerably outperforming the market overall. Bank of America, on the other hand, is down roughly 20% over the entire period, and it had a truly harrowing crash during the 2008-2009 bear market — at one point having declined by more than 90% (!!) from the April 2006 purchase price. Good example of the risk of individual stocks.
My favorite read this week was not directly finance-related at all. Rather, it’s just a brief, research-founded discussion of things that we know work to improve wellbeing in various parts..
Morningstar recently released the annual update to their “Mind the Gap” study, which looks at how well investors do with various categories of mutual funds. That is, it specifically looks at how